Styles, Pros and Cons of Antique Engagement Rings, and Where to Buy Them


Planning on getting engaged? Why not consider an antique engagement ring? Not only will it have an inherent uniqueness and charm, antique engagement rings are typically less expensive, often have better craftsmanship, and are an instant heirloom.

The Difference Between Antique Engagement Rings and Estate Engagement Rings

An "antique" engagement ring specifically refers to one over 50 years old. An estate ring is anything less than 50 years old, and may refer to a used ring bought only last year. For the most unique and charming rings, ask to see rings made before 1950. Some jewelers also use the term "vintage engagement ring" which different jewelers mean to use different things. While most use it as a catch-all term meaning "an old ring", others use it to mean a ring that was made to look like it was from another era; for example, a ring made in 1940 that has the filigree look of the Edwardian era.

Typical Styles of Different Eras

Victorian Antique Engagement Rings (1835-1900) often set in yellow or rose gold, Victorian rings have both simple elegant designs to very intricate ones. With the newfound wealth of the Industrial Revolution, and the new discovery of diamond mines in South Africa, many Victorian settings feature rows of diamonds, cut with an extra facet on the bottom (Called "mine cut"). Many Victorian rings also included pearls, although these are not recommended for every day wear. The classic Tiffany six-prong diamond solitaire was introduced in 1886!

Edwardian Engagement Rings (1900-1920) When the oxyacetylene torch was invented, platinum became the vogue metal for antique engagement rings. Jewelers began crafting lacy and pierced shapes, milgraining, scrollwork, and filigree detail on the mountings. Along with rose-cut diamonds, brilliant sapphires were especially popular during the Edwardian era.

Art Deco Engagement Rings (1920-1930)

The 20s were an age of machinery, exploration, jazz, and exoticism. Art Deco antique engagement rings reflect the era with a streamlined geometric look. They also often reflect fashion trends of the era, with allusions to Egyptian, Asian, and Native American cultures. Early Art Deco rings diverged from pale Edwardian designs with colorful, contrasting gemstones, although soon went to a platinum diamond-packed look for a glittering streamlined look, ala the Chrysler Building. Art Deco rings are currently the most popular antique engagement rings for newly engaged couples.

Things to Keep in Mind About Antique Engagement Rings

While diamonds are currently the most popular stone for engagement bands, this wasn't always true. Be careful of softer stones such as emerald, pearl, and opal, which may have internal cracks or may be easily damaged.

Look carefully at the craftsmanship of the ring. This is often what makes a difference when buying an antique engagement ring. If you were to try to commission a modern jeweler to match the work on an Edwardian ring, you would end up spending many times more than what you'd pay for an authentic ring of the era. Avoid poor replica rings which mimic the style, but can't hold a candle to the quality and character of an older ring.

If you are on a budget, but want the look of a larger diamond, consider an antique engagement ring from the 1930s or 40s. The diamonds in these bands were often set in an elaborately carved setting which made the diamond appear larger.

Remember that today's standards of quality don't necessarily apply to older diamonds; while bright white is now considered the best diamond, people once searched for slightly rose, green or yellow diamonds. Methods of cutting were different, and the scientific ability to see internal flaws was not as advanced. The most important thing is that you and your fiancé love your antique engagement ring.

Where to Buy an Antique Engagement Ring

Whenever purchasing antique jewelry, look carefully at the descriptions of each piece. Make sure they will give you, in writing, a complete description of the piece, including age, size, condition, color, carat, clarity, and cut. Preferably, they will have a certified gemologists report for you. As with any sizeable purchase, you'll want to ask all of your questions about the piece before you hand over a check. And make sure you know the return policy, should you be unhappy with your purchase.

Antique Engagement Rings can be found at a variety of places including antique stores, jewelers, estate sales, pawn shops and online. I advise that a novice buyer should stick to jewelers and antique jewelry specialists, who will be able to guide you in your purchase. Always make sure you are going to a reputable seller.

Elsarings.com doesn't deliver on custom sapphire ring
I bought myself a beautiful sapphire several years ago and finally had the money to have it set. I contacted a few different jewelers and chose one based on price and also whoever contacted me back. ...

Consumer Complaints: Amazon.com uses shady practices with it's own sellers
I'm not going to use my real email address as we all know what happens to sellers who speak the "truth" about Amazon selling. They get canned. ....

Consumer Complaints: Blue Niles Break Half-Price Promises
Dollsome reader Paige C. writes in about the tragic mislaying of one of her Blue Nile earrings. It is rather predictably followed by a smattering of appalling customer service on Blue Nile’s part after they promise (then deny) her a half-priced replacement

Complaints about Zales Jewelry - Customers being ripped off
Christmas 2000, my husband bought me a heart-shaped diamond necklace from Zales Jewelry located at the Southern Hills Mall in Sioux City, Iowa at a cost of $212.96. Just before Christmas 2001, I noticed that two of the diamonds were missing, so I took it back to the mall store to be repaired. That was the last time I saw it!!

ShopNBC jewelry Scams and consumer complaints
Mary of Spring Hill, FL, purchased $10,000+ in jewelry from Shop NBC only to find that many of the pieces were not as described. The diamonds were not the quality as stated on the site and by host. Major stones were cracked, broken and even missing when they arrived.

Ebay users fed up with fakes
Rogers thought she had snagged a great deal on Ebay. But when the jewelry arrived from a seller in Rhode Island, her well-trained eye told her all the pieces were knockoffs.

UPS - Lost Jewelry Case
UPS loses $15,000 Diamond Ring and leaves customer empty handed.

Chicago Jeweler Accused of "Cyber-Squatting"
With the online Christmas shopping season in full swing, Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan is suing a Chicago area jewelry store that she says unfairly took business away from its competitors and deceived online shoppers by using copycat Web addresses to redirect consumers from their intended Internet destinations.